From Decisionism to Rational Choice: A History of Political Decision-Making in the 20th Century

erc

Starting Grant (StG), SH6, ERC-2011-StG

Project acronym: HIPODEMA

Project: From Decisionism to Rational Choice: A History of Political Decision-Making in the 20th Century

Researcher (PI): Nicolas Michel Boian Guilhot

Host Institution (HI): Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, France

Start date: 2011-12-01, End date: 2016-11-30

Summary: «Historians have good reasons to be highly suspicious of the “rational choice” methodologies that hold sway in economics, political science or sociology and that find a new lease on life today with the rise of the cognitive sciences. On the other hand, researchers using these methodologies show usually very little interest in history. The result is that we know very little about the historical development of “rational choice” as a way to define rationality in action, while this intellectual paradigm has become pervasive and reshaped the way we do science and the way we think about politics. This project will follow the problem of decision-making through the 20th century and weave into a single historical narrative its different disciplinary formulations. It starts with a puzzle: while the “decisionist” critiques of legality of the 1920s associated the decision with an anti-rationalist vision of politics, this notion gradually morphed into the epitome of “rational choice” after 1945. How did this transformation occur? The project will reconstruct this shift from a paradigm in which Law was the instrument that would make political decisions rational, to another in which the power of rationalization was vested in Science. It asks how the post-1945 efforts at specifying conditions of rationality for political decisions changed the meaning of “rationality.” It connects these developments to the interdisciplinary set of “decision sciences” that emerged in the 1950s around issues of strategic and political behavior and spawned our contemporary instruments of “conflict-resolution” or automated models of decision-making. The project suggests that “rationality” in political decision-making is not a transcendental norm, but a historically contingent benchmark dependent on its technical instrumentations. Democratizing political decision-making, then, means opening these models and instruments of rationalization to scholarly debate and public scrutiny.»

Recomendados

Using Historical Quasi-Experiments to Understand the Knowledge Economy

Starting Grant (StG), SH1, ERC-2013-StG Project acronym: HISKNOWL Project: Using Historical Quasi-Experiments to Understand the Knowledge Economy Researcher (PI): Fabian Waldinger Host Institution (HI): The University of Warwick, United Kingdom

PROduction and CONsumption: Textile Economy and Urbanisation in Mediterranean Europe 1000-500 BCE

Starting Grant (StG), SH6, ERC-2012-StG Project acronym: PROCON Project: PROduction and CONsumption: Textile Economy and Urbanisation in Mediterranean Europe 1000-500 BCE Researcher (PI): Margarita Gleba Host Institution (HI): The University

Economics in the Public Sphere: USA, UK, France, Brazil and Argentina since 1945

Starting Grant (StG), SH2, ERC-2011-StG Project acronym: ECONPUBLIC Project: Economics in the Public Sphere: USA, UK, France, Brazil and Argentina since 1945 Researcher (PI): Tiago Jorge Fernandes Da Mata Host

Ageism: A Multi-National, Interdisciplinary Perspective

COST IS1402 Project: Ageism: A Multi-National, Interdisciplinary Perspective Chair: Liat Ayalon Start date: 2014-11-19, End date: 2018-11-18   Objectives: The aim of this Action proposal is to enhance scientific knowledge

FIGHT – Fighting Monopolies, Defying Empires 1500-1750: a Comparative Overview of Free Agents and Informal Empires in Western Europe and the Ottoman Empire

Starting Grant (StG), SH6, ERC-2012-StG Project acronym: FIGHT Project: FIGHT – Fighting Monopolies, Defying Empires 1500-1750: a Comparative Overview of Free Agents and Informal Empires in Western Europe and the

The medieval plagues: ecology, transmission modalities and routes of the infections

Advanced Grant (AdG), SH6, ERC-2012-ADG Project acronym: MEDPLAG Project: The medieval plagues: ecology, transmission modalities and routes of the infections. Researcher (PI): Barbara Bramanti Host Institution (HI): Universitetet I Oslo,